The Show's Logo.

In this thrilling murder mystery reality show, a group of contestants known as "investigators" must solve a crime that has taken place as Blackwell Grange. A murder.

Each investigator is then briefed on what is known, and it is then up to them to solve the clues, and riddles around the house as well as interviewing the witnesses, and resitdents to find out which guest has been secretly lying about their innocence. The twist to the game is that one contestant is lying. One contestant isn't really an investigator at all, they're an accomplice. They helped with the crime, and are now working to frame someone else. The goal is to find out who the killer and the accomplice is, and how they commited the crime. Whichever investigator correctly solves the crime at the end of the series walks away with $100,000 dollars cash. However, whoever is deemed to deliver the weakest investigation each week will be dismissed and be out of the running to win the show.

The suspects are to the right.

One of the 12 men and women in the picture has commited an awful crime, while the other eleven are innocent.

Season detailsEdit

Season # of Investigators Winner Runner-Up Accomplice(s) Killer Viewers
Clue 1 13 Gregory Flatts Samantha LeBlanc Regine Francis Rusty Nayler 7.4m
Clue 2 13 Natalie Brown "Allie" Mole Roy Hornsby Rusty Nayler 6.2m
Clue 3 14 Laura Borden Kristen Anderson Ceri Hazelwood Miss Scarlett 5.025m
Matthew "Matt" Garnier
Clue 4 13 Calvin Small Kendra Bailey Danielle Heuser Miss Peach 4.41m
Clue 5 14 Amy Yee Morgan Duenk Cleo Yokofski Prof. Plum 5.5m
All Stars 14 Rebecca Thomas "Allie" Mole De'rel Shaw Prince Azure 8.95m
Clue 7 15 "Ross" Finland Rachel Wright Karen Hickey Col. Mustard 7.6m
Clue 8 15 Ari Jigello Ezequiel Brooks Tony James Mrs. White 8.01m
Couples 20 Davis Moore Laura Crawford (2nd) Craig Hanlon Mrs. Peacock 5.6m
Brooke Burns (3rd)
Clue 10 13 Eryn Stewert Chandi Gilmore Giorgio Eatmon Rusty Nayler 6.3m
16 Bhriana Delarosa Phelicia Bleu Adriano Pedro Prince Azure 6.7m
All Stars 15 Tony James Adriano Pedro Laura Crawford Mrs. White 6.41m
Clue 13 14 Evan Parker Katerina Austen Jih Thao Rusty Nayler 7.0m
Clue 14 13 "Ed" Rio Natalie Pac Carolana Martinez Mrs. White 7.0m
Old&New 14 Yul Huang Laura Lafayette Kieran MacDonald Mrs. Peacock 8.1m
Clue 16 14 Heather Smithson Candice Brown Emerald Finlay Prince Azure 7.64m
Clue 17 14 "Danni" Richardmyer Teri Boyd Mailyss O'Deagen Prince Azure 7.02m

Season 1Edit

Investigator Age Occupation Outcome
Gregory Flatts 36 Real Estate Agent Winner
Regine Francis 64 Retired Teacher Accomplice
Samantha LeBlanc 19 Model Runner-Up
Rebecca Thomas 34 TV News Anchor Eliminated Finale
Ashley Markhs 20 University Student/Part-time Cashier Eliminated Episode 9
Frank Tobin 45 Fire Fighter Eliminated Episode 8
Klarke Manson 40 Plumber Eliminated Episode 7
Yvette Griswald 49 Stay-at-Home Mom Eliminated Episode 6
Roudalf Dellano 64 Retired Pilot Eliminated Episode 5
Olivia Carmichael 27 Fashion Designer Eliminated Episode 4
Mark Leblouski 50 Lawyer Eliminated Episode 3
Rachel Casey 30 Special Ed. Teacher Eliminated Episode 2
Rascal Carmichael 30 Aspiring Country Music Artist Eliminated Episode 1
  • Rascal & Olivia are brother and sister.
Contestants Episodes
Gregory 2nd 3rd BTM 3 4th WIN 4th 3rd WIN BTM 2 WINWINNER
Regine BTM 3 6th 3rd 5th 5th 2nd 4th 4th 3rd 2ndACCOMPLICE
Samantha 6th WIN 2nd 3rd 3rd BTM 2 BTM 2 BTM 2 WIN 3rd SECOND
Rebecca WIN BTM 2 WIN BTM 2 6th 5th 5th 2nd 2nd OUT
Ashley 8th 2nd 5th BTM 3 7th 3rd 2nd 3rd OUT
Frank 4th 8th BTM 2 7th 4th 6th WIN OUT
Klarke 3rd 9th 8th 6th 2nd WIN OUT
Yvette 5th 4th 6th WIN BTM 2 OUT
Roudalf 10th 7th 7th 2nd OUT
Olivia BTM 2 5th 4th OUT
Mark 7th BTM 3 OUT
Rachel 9th OUT
Rascal OUT
  • Contestants are ranked each week from best to worst based on how good of an investigation they produced that week. Whoever delivers the best pitch wins for that respective week and earns $500 which will be added to the pot if they win. The worst pitches will be rewarded with a spot in the elimination chamber where whoever out of the bottom group has given the weakest cases consistantly will be eliminated

Season 2Edit

Investigator Age Occupation Outcome
Natalie Brown 29 Nurse Winner
Roy Hornsby 56 High School Teacher/Football Coach Accomplice
Aleksandra "Allie" Mole 19 Model Runner-Up
Issabel White 21 Aspiring Designer Eliminated Finale
Timothy "Tim" Russell 20 Construction Worker Eliminated Episode 9
Angel Symone 18 Student/Model Eliminated Episode 8
Claire Meoh 19 Retail Associate Eliminated Episode 7
Tammy DeWolfe 46 Accountant Eliminated Episode 6
Lachlan Earch 34 Model Eliminated Episode 5
Aaron Patterson 27 Wedding Photographer Eliminated Episode 4
Ciera Marsch 24 Student Eliminated Episode 3
Ronald "Ron" Blois 70 Retired Engineer Eliminated Episode 2
Jonnie Harmonton 26 Surfing Instructor Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants Episodes
Natalie WIN WIN 6th 7th 2nd 5th WIN BTM 2 2nd WIN WINNER
Roy 10th 9th WIN BTM 3WIN 6th 4th 2nd WIN2nd ACCOMPLICE
Allie 9th 6th 7th 2nd 6th WIN 2nd WIN BTM 2 3rd SECOND
Issabel BTM 3 5th BTM 2 5th 3rd 2nd 3rd 4th 3rd OUT
Tim 4th 4th 5th 3rd BTM 2 4th 5th 3rd OUT
Angel 7th 3rd 3rd WIN 4th 3rd BTM 2 OUT
Claire 3rd 2nd BTM 3 4th 5th BTM 2OUT
Tammy 5th 8th 8th BTM 2 7th OUT
Lachlan 2nd 7th 2nd 6th OUT
Aaron 8th BTM 2 4th OUT
Ciera 6th BTM 3 OUT
Jonnie OUT

Season 3Edit

Investigator Age Occupation Outcome
Laura Borden 47 Postal Worker Winner
Ceri Hazelwood 29 Nanny Accomplice
Matthew "Matt" Garnier 34 Parametic Accomplice
Kristen Anderson 19 Camp Councelor Runner-Up
Blake Hart 20 Student Eliminated Episode 9
Claudette Manson 62 Sunday School Teacher Eliminated Episode 8
Laura Richardson 24 Retail Manager Eliminated Episode 7
De'rel Shaw 25 Door-to-Door Salesman Eliminated Episode 7
Shaun Pittsburgh 33 Attorney Eliminated Episode 6
Lukas "Luke" Powell 27 Stay-at-Home Dad Eliminated Episode 5
Molly Stewart 60 Librarian Eliminated Episode 4
Lucas Kyle 23 Model Eliminated Episode 3
Francesca Palliotti 24 Model Eliminated Episode 2
Jonas Fei 39 Sous Chef Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants Episodes
Laura B. 5th 6th 7thWIN 3rd WIN WIN 2nd 2nd WIN WINNER
Ceri WIN 3rd 4th BTM 3 4th BTM 2 2nd 3rd BTM 2 3rd ACCOMPLICE
Matt 3rd BTM 3 3rd 5th WIN 5th 4th WIN WIN 2nd ACCOMPLICE
Kristen 4th 2nd 5th 7th 8th 3rd BTM 3 BTM 2 3rd SECOND
Blake BTM 2 4th 8th 3rd 2nd 6th 5th 4th OUT
Claudette 10th 8th 9th 8th 5th 7th 3rd OUT
Laura R. 7th 7th WIN 6th BTM 2 2nd OUT
De'rel 2nd WIN 6th BTM 2 6th 4th OUT
Shaun 6th 10th BTM 2 2nd 7th OUT
Luke 8th BTM 2 2nd 4th OUT
Molly 9th 5th BTM 3 OUT
Lucas BTM 3 9th OUT
Francesca 11th OUT
Jonas OUT

Season 4Edit

Investigator Age Occupation Outcome
Calvin Small 24 Student/Model Winner
Danielle Hueser 25 Entrepreneur Accomplice
Kendra Bailey 24 Stylist Runner-Up
Gage Rue 29 Tattoo Artist Eliminated Finale
Lindsay Carrier 30 Human Resources Manager Eliminated Episode 9
Sheiry McLeod 43 Teacher Eliminated Episode 8
Chloe Leonard 28 Dancing Instructor Eliminated Episode 7
Lou Ann Montgomery 50 Crossing Guard Eliminated Episode 6
Noah Lewis 20 Student Eliminated Episode 5
Shaw Sparks 18 Student Eliminated Episode 4
Jorge Herrera 47 Janitor Eliminated Episode 3
Allison Hartly 24 Unemployed Eliminated Episode 2
Dominic O'Halloran 25 Special Effects Artist Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants Episodes
Calvin 9th 3rd 8th 2nd 3rd 4th BTM 2 BTM 2 2nd 2nd WINNER
Danielle 3rd 5th 5th 5th 7th 6th 2nd 4th BTM 2 3rd ACCOMPLICE
Kendra 2nd 2nd BTM 3 3rd 6th BTM 2 4th WIN 3rd WIN SECOND
Gage WIN BTM 3 4th BTM 2 WIN 2nd 5th 2nd WIN OUT
Lindsay 8th 9th 3rd WIN 4th 3rd 3rd 3rd OUT
Sheiry 5th 8th 7th 7th BTM 2 WINWIN OUT
Chloe 6th 7th WIN 6th 5th 5th OUT
Lou Ann BTM 3 WIN 2nd BTM 3 2nd OUT
Noah 7th BTM 2 6th 4th OUT
Shaw 4th 6th BTM 2 OUT
Jorge BTM 2 4th OUT
Allison 10th OUT
Dominic OUT

Season 5Edit

Investigator Age Occupation Outcome
Amy Yee 24 Film Student Winner
Cleo Yokofski 64 Retired Teacher Accomplice
Morgan Duenk 24 Model Runner-Up
Brandon Gallant 23 Barista Eliminated Finale
Evan Marshall 30 OBGYN Doctor Eliminated Episode 9
Ola Noordwyck 54 Custodian Eliminated Episode 8
Steven March 50 Private Investigator Eliminated Episode 7
Bhriana Delarosa 18 Model Eliminated Episode 6
Max Lynn 24 Personal Shopper Eliminated Episode 5
Nich Levesque 18 Student Eliminated Episode 4
Marlee O'Tallon 35 Hotel Sales Manager Eliminated Episode 3
Nathaniel McNeal 19 Student Eliminated Episode 3
Julie Remaros 24 Bartender Eliminated Episode 2
Alec Rodgers 27 Lab Technician Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants Episodes
Amy 7th WIN 7th BTM 2 4th 4th 4th BTM 2 2nd WINWINNER
Cleo 9th 4th 3rd 5th 2nd WIN 2nd WIN BTM 2 3rdACCOMPLICE
Morgan BTM 3 7th 2nd 2nd WIN 2nd 3rd 3rd WIN 2nd SECOND
Brandon WIN 6th WINBTM 3 5th 5th WIN 4th 3rdOUT
Evan 4th BTM 3 BTM 3 WIN 3rd 3rd 5th 2nd OUT
Ola 6th 2nd 4th 3rd BTM 2 BTM 2 BTM 2 OUT
Steven 5th BTM 2 8th 4th 7th 7th OUT
Bhriana BTM 2 9th 6th 7th 6th OUT
Max 10th 3rd 5th 6th OUT
Nich 2nd 10th 9th OUT
Marlee 8th 8th OUT
Nathaniel 3rd 5th OUT
Julie 11th OUT
Alec OUT

Season 6 - All StarsEdit

Investigator Age Occupation Previous Outcome
Rebecca Thomas 34 TV News Anchor Season 1 3rd Winner
De'rel Shaw 25 Door-to-Door Salesman Season 3 6th Accomplice
Aleksandra "Allie" Mole 19 Model Season 2 Runner-Up Runner-Up
Ola Noordwyck 54 Custodian Season 5 5th Eliminated Episode 11
Ceri Hazelwood 29 Nanny Season 3 Accomplice Eliminated Episode 10
Natalie Brown 29 Nurse Season 2 Winner Eliminated Episode 9
Gage Rue 29 Tattoo Artist Season 4 3rd Eliminated Episode 8
Samantha LeBlanc 19 Model Season 1 Runner-Up Eliminated Episode 7
Matthew "Matt" Garnier 34 Parametic Season 3 Accomplice Eliminated Episode 6
Lou Ann Montgomery 50 Crossing Guard Season 4 7th Eliminated Episode 5
Laura Borden 47 Postal Worker Season 3 Winner Eliminated Episode 4
Gregory Flatts 36 Real Estate Agent Season 1 Winner Eliminated Episode 3
Angel Symone 18 Student/Model Season 2 5th Eliminated Episode 2
Roy Hornsby 56 Football Coach Season 2 Accomplice Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants Episodes
Rebecca 5th BTM 3 5th 6th WIN 2nd 6th BTM 2 3rd BTM 2 2nd WINNER
De'rel 8th 9th 6th 7th 2nd WIN 2nd 5th 4th 2nd 3rd ACCOMPLICE
Allie 3rd 3rd 9th 4th 6th 5th WIN WIN BTM 2 3rd WIN SECOND
Ola 10th WIN WIN 2nd 5th 7th BTM 2 4th 2nd WIN OUT
Ceri 2nd 8th 8th 8th 7th BTM 2 3rd 2nd WIN OUT
Natalie 9th 2nd BTM 2WIN 4th 3rd 5th 3rd OUT
Gage WIN 6th 4th BTM 3 8th 6th 4th OUT
Samantha 4th 5th 7th 3rd 3rd 4th OUT
Matt 6th 4th BTM 3 5th BTM 2 OUT
Lou Ann 7th BTM 2 2nd BTM 2 OUT
Laura 11th 10th 3rd OUT
Gregory BTM 3 7th OUT
Angel BTM 2 OUT

Season 7Edit

Investigator Age Occupation Outcome
Roscoe "Ross" Finland 45 Stay-at-Home Dad Winner
Karen Hickey 54 Retail Associate Accomplice
Rachel Wright 24 Teacher Runner-Up
Ellenmarie Gibson 68 Retired Sales Manager Eliminated Finale
Blare Rydeout 18 Student Eliminated Finale
Grendel Moore 65 Retired Flight Attendant Eliminated Episode 9
Karen-Jayne "K.J." Lutz 49 Radio Announcer Eliminated Episode 8
Michael "Mike" Rosales 36 Personal Trainer Eliminated Episode 7
Frankie Mahone 27 Photographer Eliminated Episode 6
Lynsay O'Ryan 26 Exotic Dancer Eliminated Episode 5
Jolie Chin 24 Student Eliminated Episode 4
Gene Quinlon 56 Loss Prevention Manager Eliminated Episode 3
Robert "Rob" MacFarland 36 Hotel Manager Eliminated Episode 2
Erinly "Erin" Southwick 19 Model Eliminated Episode 2
Jillian MacLean 29 Social Worker Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants Episodes
Ross 5th 10th 6th 3rd 4th BTM 2 3rd WIN 3rd WIN WINNER
Karen 7th WIN 2nd 4th 6th 5th BTM 2 3rd 2nd 3rd ACCOMPLICE
Rachel WIN 11th BTM 3 5th WIN 4th 5th 2nd WIN 2nd SECOND
Ellenmarie BTM 2 5th WIN WIN 5th 2nd WIN 5th BTM 2 OUT
Blare 3rd 6th 4th 6th BTM 3 7th 2nd BTM 2 4th OUT
Grendel 4th 8th BTM 2 BTM 2 3rd 3rd 6th 4th OUT
K.J. 10th 9th 3rd 7th 2nd 6th 4th OUT
Mike 8th 3rd 8th BTM 3 7th WIN OUT
Frankie 9th 2nd 5th 8th BTM 2 OUT
Lynsay BTM 4 7th 7th 2nd OUT
Jolie BTM 3 4th 9th OUT
Gene 2nd BTM 3 OUT
Rob 6th OUT
Erin 11th OUT
Jillian OUT

Season 8Edit

Investigator Age Occupation Outcome
Ari Jigello 27 Event Organizer Winner
Tony James 44 Resturant Manager Accomplice
Ezequiel Brooks 18 Student Runner-Up
Renata Reyes 24 Model Eliminated Finale
Cameron Applegate 18 Student Eliminated Episode 9
Monica Torrey 26 Unemployed Eliminated Episode 8
Tobias Boulard 24 Artist Eliminated Episode 7
Jessica Mather 19 Model Eliminated Episode 6
Teslo Antonov 27 Musician Eliminated Episode 6
Phelicia Bleu 19 Sales Associate Eliminated Episode 5
Sprague Greenwich 25 Actress Eliminated Episode 4
Kim Yu 25 Architect Eliminated Episode 3
Michelle Toro 28 Investment Banker Eliminated Episode 2
Marvin Flores 19 Student Eliminated Episode 1
Adriano Pedro 26 Chef Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants Episodes
Ari WIN 8th 3rd 3rd BTM 2BTM 3 4th 4th 2nd 3rdWINNER
Tony 5th 4th BTM 2 6th WIN WIN 2nd WIN BTM 2 2nd ACCOMPLICE
Ezequiel 9th 6th 5th WIN 2nd 6th 3rd 2nd WIN WIN SECOND
Renata 2nd WIN 2nd BTM 3 BTM 3 2nd BTM 2BTM 2 3rd OUT
Cameron 4th 2nd 9th 7th 6th 5th 5th 3rd OUT
Monica 11th BTM 2 8th 5th 4th 4th WIN OUT
Tobias 8th 5th 7th 4th 7th 3rd OUT
Jessica 7th BTM 3 4th 8th 5th OUT
Teslo 3rd 3rd BTM 3 BTM 2 3rd OUT
Phelicia BTM 2 9th 6th 2nd OUT
Sprague 10th 10th WIN OUT
Kim 6th 7th OUT
Michelle BTM 3 OUT
Marvin OUT

Season 9 - CouplesEdit

Investigator Age Occupation Relationship Outcome
Davis Moore 23 PHD Student Step-Brothers Winner
Craig Hanlon 27 Construction Worker Accomplice
Laura Crawford 24 NFL Cheerleader Teammates Runner-Up
Brooke Burns 24 NFL Cheerleader Third Place
Rachel Clawson 30 Human Resource Manager Childhood Friends Eliminated Episode 6
Rachel Dwyer 29 Shoe Designer
Brandon Stevenson 20 Student Dating Eliminated Episode 6
Tiffany Emerald 20 Student
Bianca Richards 24 Massage Therapist Dating Eliminated Episode 5
Ryan Alexa 30 Teacher
Jane Myers 58 Cafeteria Chef Mother/Son Eliminated Episode 4
Evan Myers 25 Software Developer
Penelope Granger 49 Social Worker Mother/Daughter Eliminated Episode 3
Samantha Granger 18 Student
Kile Martin 19 Student Siblings Eliminated Episode 2
Kaitlin Martin 24 Model/Bartender
Dale Scout 47 Correctional Officer Best Friends Eliminated Episode 1
Rex Gharrington 49 Mechanic
David "Dave" Paul 65 Retired Cop Grandparents Eliminated Episode 1
Janet Paul 60 Retail Manager
Contestants Episodes
WIN 5th 3rd 4th BTM 2 WIN 2nd SECOND
4th 6th 4th 3rd 2nd 2ndOUT
5th 2nd 2nd BTM 2 WIN OUT
6th 4th BTM 2 2nd OUT
2nd BTM 2 5th OUT
BTM 2 3rd OUT
7th OUT

Season 10Edit

Investigator Age Occupation Outcome
Eryn Stewert 18 Student Winner
Giorgio Eatmon 39 Lawyer Accomplice
Chandi Gilmore 40 Stay-at-Home Mother Runner-Up
Nicole Dennings 30 Lawyer Eliminated Finale
Ashley Laurence 19 Student Eliminated Episode 9
Louise Freeman 54 Bank Teller Eliminated Episode 8
Drew Haskel 19 Model Eliminated Episode 7
Jennifer Graham-Treatonhill 36 Television Producer Eliminated Episode 6
Darieul Strauss 19 Student Eliminated Episode 5
Scot Fellos 40 Retail Clerk Eliminated Episode 4
Jimmy April 43 Record Store Owner Eliminated Episode 3
Maximo Donati 18 Student Eliminated Episode 2
Amanda McGraw 28 Human Resource Manager Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants Episodes
Eryn 2nd BTM 3 7th WIN BTM 2 6th 2nd WIN WIN WINWINNER
Giorgio 9th 3rd 2nd 6th 5th 4th BTM 2 2nd 3rd 2nd ACCOMPLICE
Chandi 3rd 2nd 3rd 3rd 2nd 5th 5th BTM 2 BTM 2 3rdSECOND
Nicole WIN WIN 6th 7th 3rd 3rd WIN 3rd 2nd OUT
Ashley 7th 6th 5th BTM 2 7th WIN 4th 4th OUT
Louise 6th 7th BTM 3 4th WIN 2nd 3rd OUT
Drew BTM 2 4th WIN BTM 3 4th BTM 2 OUT
Jennifer 5th 9th BTM 2 5th 6th OUT
Darieul 4th BTM 2 8th 2nd OUT
Scot BTM 3 5th 4th OUT
Jimmy 10th 8th OUT
Maximo 8th OUT
Amanda OUT

Season 11 - Second ChancesEdit

Investigator Age Previous Outcome
Bhriana Delarosa 18 Season 5 7th Winner
Adriano Pedro 26 Season 8 14th Accomplice
Phelicia Bleu 19 Season 8 9th Runner-Up
Jillian McLean 29 Season 7 14th Eliminated Finale
Olivia Carmichael 27 Season 1 9th Eliminated Episode 9
Jolie Chin 24 Season 7 10th Eliminated Episode 8
Max Lynn 24 Season 5 8th Eliminated Episode 7
Marlee O'Tallon 35 Season 5 10th Eliminated Episode 6
Ciera Marsch 24 Season 2 10th Eliminated Episode 5
Lynsay O'Ryan 26 Season 7 9th Eliminated Episode 4
Yvette Griswald 49 Season 1 7th Eliminated Episode 3
Kaitlin Martin 24 Season 9 8th Eliminated Episode 3
Sprague Greenwich 30 Season 8 10th Eliminated Episode 2
Maximo Donati 18 Season 10 11th Eliminated Episode 1
Rascal Carmichael 30 Season 1 12th Eliminated Episode 1
Lachlan Earch 34 Season 2 8th Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants Episodes
Bhriana BTM 5 3rd 4th BTM 2 2nd 6th 3rd 4th 2nd 2ndWINNER
Adriano 4th 2nd 6th 4th WIN 5th WIN BTM 2 BTM 2 3rd ACCOMPLICE
Phelicia 6th 9th WIN 5th 5th 2nd 4th 2nd WIN WIN SECOND
Jillian WIN 5th 2nd 7th BTM 2 WIN BTM 2 3rd 3rd OUT
Olivia 9th WIN 9th 2nd 4th BTM 2 2nd WIN OUT
Jolie 3rd 7th 3rd 3rd 6th 4th 5th OUT
Max 10th 6th BTM 3 WIN 7th 3rd OUT
Marlee 2nd 8th 8th BTM 3 3rd OUT
Ciera 5th BTM 3 7th 6th OUT
Lynsay BTM 4 4th 5th OUT
Yvette 7th 10th OUT
Kaitlin 8th BTM 2 OUT
Sprague BTM 3 OUT
Rascal OUT
Maximo OUT

Season 12 - All StarsEdit

Investigator Age Occupation Previous Outcome
Tony James 44 Resturant Manager Season 8 Accomplice Winner
Laura Crawford 24 NFL Cheerleader Season 9 2nd Accomplice
Adriano Pedro 26 Chef Season 8/11 14th/Accomplice Runner-Up
Chandi Gilmore 40 Stay-at-Home Mother Season 10 2nd Eliminated Episode 10
Davis Moore 23 PHD Student Season 9 Winner Eliminated Episode 9
Rachel Wright 24 Teacher Season 7 2nd Eliminated Episode 8
Giorgio Eatmon 39 Lawyer Season 10 Accomplice Eliminated Episode 7
Craig Hanlon 27 Construction Worker Season 9 Accomplice Eliminated Episode 6
Jillian McLean 19 Social Worker Season 7/11 14th/3rd Eliminated Episode 5
Karen Hickey 54 Retail Associate Season 7 Accomplice Eliminated Episode 4
Ezequiel Brooks 18 Student Season 8 2nd Eliminated Episode 4
Nicole Dennings 30 Lawyer Season 10 3rd Eliminated Episode 3
Ellenmarie Gibson 68 Retired Sales Manager Season 7 3rd Eliminated Episode 3
Renata Reyes 24 Model Season 8 3rd Eliminated Episode 2
Phelicia Bleu 19 Sales Associate Season 8/11 9th/2nd Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants Episodes
Tony 8th WIN 6th WIN 3rd 6th BTM 2 3rd 3rd 3rd WINNER
Laura WIN 11th 2nd 4th 6th 3rd 5th 2nd BTM 2 2nd ACCOMPLICE
Adriano 7th 6th 3rd 8th WIN 2nd 4th BTM 2 WIN WINSECOND
Chandi BTM 4 2nd 7th 2nd 4th BTM 2 WIN WIN 2nd OUT
Davis 5th 10th 9th 6th 2nd WIN 3rd 4th OUT
Rachel 2nd 8th 4th 3rd BTM 2 5th 2nd OUT
Giorgio 4th 9th BTM 3BTM 3 7th 4th OUT
Craig 10th 4th BTM 2 BTM 2 5th OUT
Jillian 11th BTM 2 WIN 5th OUT
Karen 9th BTM 3 5th OUT
Ezequiel 3rd 5th 8th OUT
Nicole BTM 2 7th OUT
Ellenmarie 6th 3rd OUT
Renata BTM 3 OUT
Phelicia OUT

Season 13Edit

Investigator Age Occupation Outcome
Evan Parker 21 Computer Progammer Winner
Jih Thao 20 Student Accomplice
Katerina Austen 19 Cashier Runner-Up
Nathally Sullivan 30 Real Estate Agent Eliminated Finale
Shmuel Frank 23 Student Eliminated Episode 9
Ishmael "Ish" Jackson 27 Dance Club D.J. Eliminated Episode 8
Jack Donnelson 40 Video Game Designer Eliminated Episode 7
Gina Anne Munroe 49 Office Manager Eliminated Episode 6
Richardo Olivero 37 Salsa Dance Instructor Eliminated Episode 6
Cristann Ritckcher 24 Student Eliminated Episode 5
Natalie Richards 26 Substitute Teacher Eliminated Episode 4
Sienna Crook-Eastlen 18 Model Eliminated Episode 3
Carlos Rigera 47 Chef Eliminated Episode 2
Malcolm "Brig" Briggs 37 Basketball Coach Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants Episodes
Evan WIN 5th BTM 3 5th 2nd 4th 5th 3rd 3rd 3rd WINNER
Jih 5th 3rd WIN 8th 3rd 2nd WIN WIN 2nd WINACCOMPLICE
Katerina 2nd 4th 9th 7th 4th 5th 2nd BTM 2 WIN 2nd SECOND
Nathally S. 3rd 10th 3rd 2nd 6th BTM 2 BTM 2 2nd BTM 2 OUT
Shmuel 7th BTM 2 7th 3rd WIN 6th 4th 4th OUT
Ish 6th WIN 4th BTM 3 BTM 2WIN 3rd OUT
Jack BTM 4 7th 5th WIN 8th 3rd OUT
Gina Anne 8th 6th 2nd 4th 7th OUT
Ricardo 9th 2nd BTM 2 6th 5th OUT
Cristann 4th BTM 3 6th BTM 2OUT
Natalie R. BTM 2 8th 8th OUT
Sienna BTM 3 9th OUT
Carlos 10th OUT
Brig OUT

Season 14Edit

Investigator Age Occupation Outcome
Eduardo "Ed" Rio 21 Band Member Winner
Carolana Martinez 45 Language Teacher Accomplice
Natalie Pac 25 Photographer Runner-Up
Nathally Sullivan 30 Real Estate Agent Eliminated Finale
Marshall Christian 23 Blogger Eliminated Episode 9
Donald "Don" Winnefreid 56 Business Owner Eliminated Episode 8
Shanus MacShannon 40 Production Assistant Eliminated Episode 8
Kellee Klazik 19 Musician Eliminated Episode 6
Ginny Mixon 42 Freelance Artist Eliminated Episode 5
Brandon Natthews 26 Law Student Eliminated Episode 4
Kristyn Macconi 18 Model Eliminated Episode 3
Carlos Maya 40 Unemployed Eliminated Episode 2
Vanessa Morgan 21 Actress Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants Episodes
Ed 5th WIN 7th 5th 4th 3rd 5th 4th 2nd 2nd WINNER
Carolana 6th 4th 2nd 7th 2nd 5th WIN 2nd WIN WINACCOMPLICE
Natalie 7th BTM 3 WIN 2nd 3rd 2nd BTM 2 3rd 3rd 3rd SECOND
Pam 2nd 2nd 4th BTM 3 6th WIN 3rd BTM 2 BTM 2 OUT
Marshall 8th 3rd BTM 3 4th BTM 2 BTM 2 4th WIN OUT
Don 3rd 6th 5th BTM 2WIN 4th 2nd OUT
Shanus WIN 7th 6th WIN 7th 6th SAVED OUT
Kellee BTM 3 8th 8th 3rd 5th OUT
Ginny BTM 2 5th BTM 2 6th OUT
Brandon 4th 9th 3rd OUT
Kristyn 9th BTM 2 OUT
Carlos 10th OUT
Vanessa OUT

Season 15 - Old & NewEdit

Investigator Age Occupation Previous Outcome
Yul Huang 30 Doctor Winner
Kieran MacDonald 19 Student The Accomplice
Laura Lafayette 19 Cheerleader Runner-Up
Jodi King 40 Stay-at-Home Mom Eliminated Finale
Cameron Taunce 24 Soccer Player Eliminated Episode 11
Monica Torrey 26 Unemployed Season 8 - 5th Eliminated Episode 10
De'rel Shaw 25 Sales Season 3/6 - 6th/Accomplice Eliminated Episode 9
Lou Ann Montgomery 50 Crossing Guard Season 4/6 - 7th/9th Eliminated Episode 7
Teslo Antonov 27 Musician Season 8 - 8th Eliminated Episode 6
Stacey Kimball 24 Fashion Designer Eliminated Episode 5
Corrinn Stanley 70 Retired Principal Eliminated Episode 4
Ola Noordwyck 54 Custodian Season 5/6 - 5th/3rd Eliminated Episode 3
Regine Francis 64 Retired Teacher Season 1 - Accomplice Eliminated Episode 2
Aleksandra "Allie" Mole 19 Model Season 2/6 - 2nd/2nd Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants Episodes
Yul 9th 4th 3rd 8th 2nd BTM2 2nd WIN WIN 3rd 3rd 3rd WINNER
Kieran BTM4 2nd 6th 3rd 5th WIN 4th 5th 4th WIN BTM2 2ndACCOMPLICE
Laura 2nd 7th 4th WIN BTM2 3rd 5th BTM2 3rd 4th 2nd WIN SECOND
Jodi 8th WIN 8th 5th WIN 4th 6th 3rd 2nd BTM2 WIN OUT
Cameron 3rd 9th 2nd 7th 4th 7th WIN 2nd BTM2 2nd OUT
Monica 6th 8th 5th 2nd 6th 2nd BTM2 4th 5th OUT
De'rel WIN 3rd BTM3 4th 7th 5th 3rd SAVED OUT
Lou Ann 7th 6th BTM2 BTM2 3rd 6th OUT
Telso 4th 10th 9th 6th 8th OUT
Stacey 5th BTM3 WIN BTM3 OUT
Corrinn BTM2 5th 7th OUT
Ola 10th BTM2 OUT
Regine BTM3 OUT
Allie OUT

Season 16Edit

Investigator Age Occupation Outcome
Heather Smithson 34 Nurse Winner
Emerald Finlay 29 Dental Hygentist Accomplice
Candice Brown 20 Student Runner-Up
Claus MacKinnon 63 Retired Air Force Marshall Eliminated Episode 11
Petra Hearon 50 Dog Breeder Eliminated Episode 11
Marcie Hanlon 40 Stay-at-Home Mom Eliminated Episode 9
Brody Blare 18 Student Eliminated Episode 8
Emmett Hughsler 25 Mechanic Eliminated Episode 7
Greyson Blois 18 Unemployed Eliminated Episode 6
Tallon Evanhoff 28 Club Promoter Eliminated Episode 5
Brandy Rihanna 26 Singer/Preformer Eliminated Episode 4
Tallah Evanhoff 28 Medical Student Eliminated Episode 3
Alec Peters 20 Model Eliminated Episode 2
Nick Verega 23 Actor Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants Episodes
Heather 2nd 2nd 4th 6th BTM2 2nd WIN BTM2 2nd 2nd 2ndWINNER
Emerald 4th 3rd WIN 2nd WIN 5th BTM2 2nd WIN BTM2 3rdACCOMPLICE
Candice 8th 8th 3rd BTM2 5th 6th 5th WIN 3rd WINWIN SECOND
Claus BTM2 7th 6th 4th 8th 3rd 4th 4th 4th 3rd OUT
Petra WIN 5th 5th WIN 4th 4th 2nd 5th BTM2 SAVED OUT
Marcie 9th 10th 9th 5th 7th 7th 3rd 3rd OUT
Brody 7th 6th BTM3 7th 6th WIN 6th OUT
Emmett 10th WIN 2nd 8th 3rd BTM2 OUT
Greyson 3rd BTM3 BTM2 3rd 2nd OUT
Tallon 5th 4th 7th BTM3OUT
Brandy 6th BTM2 8th OUT
Tallah BTM3 9th OUT
Nick OUT

Season 17Edit

Investigator Age Occupation Outcome
Danielle "Danni" Richardmyer 29 Tattoo Artist Winner
Mailyss O'Deagen 51 Special Ed. Teacher Accomplice
Teri Boyd 47 Special Ed. Teacher Runner-Up
Claus MacKinnon 63 Retired Air Force Marshall Eliminated Episode 11
Robbie "Rob" McFadzen 35 Doctor Eliminated Episode 10
Tonya Carleton 40 Business Owner Eliminated Episode 9
Kimberly "Kim" Whynlman 34 Professional Dancer Eliminated Episode 8
Scott Hughes 42 Tailor Eliminated Episode 7
Bruno Macknaloni 26 Customer Service Rep. Eliminated Episode 6
Mckenzie Greene 18 Student Eliminated Episode 5
River Del Torres 29 Recording Artist Eliminated Episode 4
Terry Ovalby 49 Football Coach Eliminated Episode 3
Jessome Peters 25 Model Eliminated Episode 2
Catherine "Cat" Morales 19 Student Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants Episodes
Danni WIN 5th 3rd 6th 7th 5th 6th 4th BTM2 3rd 2nd WINNER
Mailyss 2nd WIN 8th WIN 8th 6th 3rd 5th 3rd WIN WIN ACCOMPLICE
Teri B. 7th 8th 2nd 4th WIN 2nd 4th 2nd WIN BTM2 3rd SECOND
Sarah 5th 7th 5th 8th BTM2 7th WIN BTM2 2nd 2nd OUT
Rob BTM3 3rd 9th 5th 4th 3rd 2nd WIN 4th OUT
Tonya 6th 2nd WINBTM3 2nd BTM2 BTM2 3rd OUT
Kim 9th 6th BTM2 2nd 6th 4th 5th OUT
Scott 3rd BTM3 BTM3 BTM2 5th WIN OUT
Bruno BTM2 4th 7th 7th 3rd OUT
Mckenzie 10th 9th 6th 3rd OUT
River BTM4 10th 4th OUT
Terry O. 4th BTM2 OUT
Jessome 8th OUT
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.