FANDOM


Season 1Edit

Contestants:Edit

Name Age Home State Status
Rachel Napallo 26 Minnesota Eliminated 1st
15th Place
Michelle Kruz 25 New Mexico Eliminated 2nd
14th Place
Laura Kromwell 24 California Eliminated 3rd
13th Place
Gill Lenner 23 New York Eliminated 4th
12th Place

Heidi Garfeild-Hank

27 Maine Eliminated 5th/6th
11th/10th Place
Hope Allen 21 Illonois
Martina Trebunskaya 23

New York
(originally Romania)

Eliminated 7th
9th Place
Kelly Armstrong 19 New York Disqualified
Did Not Place
Danielle DeLio 18 New Jersey Eliminated 8th
7th Place
Natalie Bruckwehlm 18 New Hampshire Eliminated 9th
6th Place
Ashlé LeBlanc 29 florida
(originally France)
Eliminated 10th
5th Place
Stefanie Paul 23 Wyoming Eliminated 11th
4th Place
Amelie Short 19 Oregon Third Place
Second Runner-Up
Laura Tossman 23 Washington Second Place
First Runner Up
Zoe Larson 24 Arizona Chosen
Winner!

Elimination Chart:Edit

Rank Contestants Episodes
12345678910
1st Zoe HIGH DATE LOW DATE CHOSEN
2nd Laura T. DATE LOW EXCUSED
3rd Amelie LOW LOW LOW DATE EXCUSED
4th Stefanie DATE DATE LOW EXCUSED
5th Ashlé LOW LOW LOW EXCUSED
6th Natalie LOW DATE EXCUSED
7th Danielle EXCUSED
X Kelly REMOVED
9th Martina LOW LOW DATE EXCUSED
Top 11 Hope EXCUSED
Heidi HIGH EXCUSED
12th Gill EXCUSED
13th Laura K. DATE DATE EXCUSED
14th Michelle LOW EXCUSED
15th Rachel EXCUSED

Episode Notes:

  1. In Episode 2, Zoe, Heidi, and Laura K. were all considered and chosen to go on the individual date. However, at the last moment it was decided only Laura K. would participate.
  2. Despite preforming well in the competition. In the 3rd episode Laura K. was eliminated due to a popular belief she was only appearing on the show to further an acting career.
  3. In Episode 6, Kelly was removed for the use of physical violence during a heated arguement with Natalie.

Season 2Edit

Contestants:Edit

Name Age Home State Status
Donna Hurst 34 New Jersey Eliminated 1st/2nd
18th/17th Place
Sarah Reed 18 Ohio
Brande Fort 23 California Quit
Did Not Place
Rachael Phillips 27 Washington Eliminated 3rd-5th
16-14th Place
Lindsay Shaw 24 California
Nicole Patrillo 24 New York
Rebecca Listener 25 New York Eliminated 6th/7th
13th/12th Place
Lauryn Hill 21 Florida
Brittany Upshaw 18 Georgia Eliminated 8th
11th Place
Robyn MacIntyre 19 South Carolina Eliminated 9th
10th Place
Morgan Grimm 22 Michigan Eliminated 10th
9th Place
Brittney Ellis 18 Illonois Eliminated 11th
8th Place
Melanie Cole 28 Wyoming Eliminated 12th
7th Place
Elyse Scott 27 California Eliminated 13th/14th
6/5th Place
Jackie Lin 23 Toronto, Canada
Sidney Syre 26 Washington Eliminated 15th
4th Place
Andrea Molsin 19 Oregon Third Place
Second Runner-Up
Allison Rahmer 26 Texas Second Place
First Runner Up
Ashley Haines 24 Arizona Chosen
Winner!

Elimination Chart:Edit

Rank Contestants Episodes
12345678910
1st Ashley LOW DATE LOW Andrea DATE DATE CHOSEN
2nd Allison Melanie LOW LOW EXCUSED
3rd Andrea Jackie DATE EXCUSED
4th Sidney Robyn DATE EXCUSED
Top 6 Jackie DATE HIGH Robyn EXCUSED
Elyse HIGH Ashley LOW LOW EXCUSED
7th Melanie LOW LOW LOW Robyn EXCUSED
8th Brittney E. DATE DATE Ashley EXCUSED
9th Morgan DATE DATE Allison
10th Robyn DATE Morgan
11th Brittany U. EXCUSED
Top 13 Lauryn EXCUSED
Rebecca EXCUSED
Top 16 Nicole EXCUSED
Lindsay LOW EXCUSED
Rachael EXCUSED
x Brande QUIT
Top 18 Sarah EXCUSED
Donna EXCUSED

Episode Notes:

  1. Brande quit the competition after the first elimination, so in Episode 2 Lauryn entered as her replacement.
  2. In Episode 5 each girl got to vote for which girl they thought should be eliminated, Robyn recieved the most votes (3).
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.