The Show's Logo.
In this thrilling murder mystery reality show, a group of contestants known as "investigators" must solve a crime that has taken place as Blackwell Grange. A murder.
Each investigator is then briefed on what is known, and it is then up to them to solve the clues, and riddles around the house as well as interviewing the witnesses, and resitdents to find out which guest has been secretly lying about their innocence. The twist to the game is that one contestant is lying. One contestant isn't really an investigator at all, they're an accomplice. They helped with the crime, and are now working to frame someone else. The goal is to find out who the killer and the accomplice is, and how they commited the crime. Whichever investigator correctly solves the crime at the end of the series walks away with $100,000 dollars cash. However, whoever is deemed to deliver the weakest investigation each week will be dismissed and be out of the running to win the show.
The suspects are to the right.
One of the 12 men and women in the picture has commited an awful crime, while the other eleven are innocent.
Season details [ ]
Season
# of Investigators
Winner
Runner-Up
Accomplice(s)
Killer
Viewers
Clue 1
13
Gregory Flatts
Samantha LeBlanc
Regine Francis
Rusty Nayler
7.4m
Clue 2
13
Natalie Brown
"Allie" Mole
Roy Hornsby
Rusty Nayler
6.2m
Clue 3
14
Laura Borden
Kristen Anderson
Ceri Hazelwood
Miss Scarlett
5.025m
Matthew "Matt" Garnier
Clue 4
13
Calvin Small
Kendra Bailey
Danielle Heuser
Miss Peach
4.41m
Clue 5
14
Amy Yee
Morgan Duenk
Cleo Yokofski
Prof. Plum
5.5m
All Stars
14
Rebecca Thomas
"Allie" Mole
De'rel Shaw
Prince Azure
8.95m
Clue 7
15
"Ross" Finland
Rachel Wright
Karen Hickey
Col. Mustard
7.6m
Clue 8
15
Ari Jigello
Ezequiel Brooks
Tony James
Mrs. White
8.01m
Couples
20
Davis Moore
Laura Crawford (2nd)
Craig Hanlon
Mrs. Peacock
5.6m
Brooke Burns (3rd)
Clue 10
13
Eryn Stewert
Chandi Gilmore
Giorgio Eatmon
Rusty Nayler
6.3m
Second Chances
16
Bhriana Delarosa
Phelicia Bleu
Adriano Pedro
Prince Azure
6.7m
All Stars
15
Tony James
Adriano Pedro
Laura Crawford
Mrs. White
6.41m
Clue 13
14
Evan Parker
Katerina Austen
Jih Thao
Rusty Nayler
7.0m
Clue 14
13
"Ed" Rio
Natalie Pac
Carolana Martinez
Mrs. White
7.0m
Old&New
14
Yul Huang
Laura Lafayette
Kieran MacDonald
Mrs. Peacock
8.1m
Clue 16
14
Heather Smithson
Candice Brown
Emerald Finlay
Prince Azure
7.64m
Clue 17
14
"Danni" Richardmyer
Teri Boyd
Mailyss O'Deagen
Prince Azure
7.02m
Season 1 [ ]
Investigator
Age
Occupation
Outcome
Gregory Flatts
36
Real Estate Agent
Winner
Regine Francis
64
Retired Teacher
Accomplice
Samantha LeBlanc
19
Model
Runner-Up
Rebecca Thomas
34
TV News Anchor
Eliminated Finale
Ashley Markhs
20
University Student/Part-time Cashier
Eliminated Episode 9
Frank Tobin
45
Fire Fighter
Eliminated Episode 8
Klarke Manson
40
Plumber
Eliminated Episode 7
Yvette Griswald
49
Stay-at-Home Mom
Eliminated Episode 6
Roudalf Dellano
64
Retired Pilot
Eliminated Episode 5
Olivia Carmichael
27
Fashion Designer
Eliminated Episode 4
Mark Leblouski
50
Lawyer
Eliminated Episode 3
Rachel Casey
30
Special Ed. Teacher
Eliminated Episode 2
Rascal Carmichael
30
Aspiring Country Music Artist
Eliminated Episode 1
Rascal & Olivia are brother and sister.
Contestants
Episodes
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Gregory
2nd
3rd
BTM 3
4th
WIN
4th
3rd
WIN
BTM 2
WIN
WINNER
Regine
BTM 3
6th
3rd
5th
5th
2nd
4th
4th
3rd
2nd
ACCOMPLICE
Samantha
6th
WIN
2nd
3rd
3rd
BTM 2
BTM 2
BTM 2
WIN
3rd
SECOND
Rebecca
WIN
BTM 2
WIN
BTM 2
6th
5th
5th
2nd
2nd
OUT
Ashley
8th
2nd
5th
BTM 3
7th
3rd
2nd
3rd
OUT
Frank
4th
8th
BTM 2
7th
4th
6th
WIN
OUT
Klarke
3rd
9th
8th
6th
2nd
WIN
OUT
Yvette
5th
4th
6th
WIN
BTM 2
OUT
Roudalf
10th
7th
7th
2nd
OUT
Olivia
BTM 2
5th
4th
OUT
Mark
7th
BTM 3
OUT
Rachel
9th
OUT
Rascal
OUT
Contestants are ranked each week from best to worst based on how good of an investigation they produced that week. Whoever delivers the best pitch wins for that respective week and earns $500 which will be added to the pot if they win. The worst pitches will be rewarded with a spot in the elimination chamber where whoever out of the bottom group has given the weakest cases consistantly will be eliminated
Season 2 [ ]
Investigator
Age
Occupation
Outcome
Natalie Brown
29
Nurse
Winner
Roy Hornsby
56
High School Teacher/Football Coach
Accomplice
Aleksandra "Allie" Mole
19
Model
Runner-Up
Issabel White
21
Aspiring Designer
Eliminated Finale
Timothy "Tim" Russell
20
Construction Worker
Eliminated Episode 9
Angel Symone
18
Student/Model
Eliminated Episode 8
Claire Meoh
19
Retail Associate
Eliminated Episode 7
Tammy DeWolfe
46
Accountant
Eliminated Episode 6
Lachlan Earch
34
Model
Eliminated Episode 5
Aaron Patterson
27
Wedding Photographer
Eliminated Episode 4
Ciera Marsch
24
Student
Eliminated Episode 3
Ronald "Ron" Blois
70
Retired Engineer
Eliminated Episode 2
Jonnie Harmonton
26
Surfing Instructor
Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants
Episodes
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Natalie
WIN
WIN
6th
7th
2nd
5th
WIN
BTM 2
2nd
WIN
WINNER
Roy
10th
9th
WIN
BTM 3
WIN
6th
4th
2nd
WIN
2nd
ACCOMPLICE
Allie
9th
6th
7th
2nd
6th
WIN
2nd
WIN
BTM 2
3rd
SECOND
Issabel
BTM 3
5th
BTM 2
5th
3rd
2nd
3rd
4th
3rd
OUT
Tim
4th
4th
5th
3rd
BTM 2
4th
5th
3rd
OUT
Angel
7th
3rd
3rd
WIN
4th
3rd
BTM 2
OUT
Claire
3rd
2nd
BTM 3
4th
5th
BTM 2
OUT
Tammy
5th
8th
8th
BTM 2
7th
OUT
Lachlan
2nd
7th
2nd
6th
OUT
Aaron
8th
BTM 2
4th
OUT
Ciera
6th
BTM 3
OUT
Ron
BTM 2
OUT
Jonnie
OUT
Season 3 [ ]
Investigator
Age
Occupation
Outcome
Laura Borden
47
Postal Worker
Winner
Ceri Hazelwood
29
Nanny
Accomplice
Matthew "Matt" Garnier
34
Parametic
Accomplice
Kristen Anderson
19
Camp Councelor
Runner-Up
Blake Hart
20
Student
Eliminated Episode 9
Claudette Manson
62
Sunday School Teacher
Eliminated Episode 8
Laura Richardson
24
Retail Manager
Eliminated Episode 7
De'rel Shaw
25
Door-to-Door Salesman
Eliminated Episode 7
Shaun Pittsburgh
33
Attorney
Eliminated Episode 6
Lukas "Luke" Powell
27
Stay-at-Home Dad
Eliminated Episode 5
Molly Stewart
60
Librarian
Eliminated Episode 4
Lucas Kyle
23
Model
Eliminated Episode 3
Francesca Palliotti
24
Model
Eliminated Episode 2
Jonas Fei
39
Sous Chef
Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants
Episodes
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Laura B.
5th
6th
7th
WIN
3rd
WIN
WIN
2nd
2nd
WIN
WINNER
Ceri
WIN
3rd
4th
BTM 3
4th
BTM 2
2nd
3rd
BTM 2
3rd
ACCOMPLICE
Matt
3rd
BTM 3
3rd
5th
WIN
5th
4th
WIN
WIN
2nd
ACCOMPLICE
Kristen
4th
2nd
5th
7th
8th
3rd
BTM 3
BTM 2
3rd
SECOND
Blake
BTM 2
4th
8th
3rd
2nd
6th
5th
4th
OUT
Claudette
10th
8th
9th
8th
5th
7th
3rd
OUT
Laura R.
7th
7th
WIN
6th
BTM 2
2nd
OUT
De'rel
2nd
WIN
6th
BTM 2
6th
4th
OUT
Shaun
6th
10th
BTM 2
2nd
7th
OUT
Luke
8th
BTM 2
2nd
4th
OUT
Molly
9th
5th
BTM 3
OUT
Lucas
BTM 3
9th
OUT
Francesca
11th
OUT
Jonas
OUT
Season 4 [ ]
Investigator
Age
Occupation
Outcome
Calvin Small
24
Student/Model
Winner
Danielle Hueser
25
Entrepreneur
Accomplice
Kendra Bailey
24
Stylist
Runner-Up
Gage Rue
29
Tattoo Artist
Eliminated Finale
Lindsay Carrier
30
Human Resources Manager
Eliminated Episode 9
Sheiry McLeod
43
Teacher
Eliminated Episode 8
Chloe Leonard
28
Dancing Instructor
Eliminated Episode 7
Lou Ann Montgomery
50
Crossing Guard
Eliminated Episode 6
Noah Lewis
20
Student
Eliminated Episode 5
Shaw Sparks
18
Student
Eliminated Episode 4
Jorge Herrera
47
Janitor
Eliminated Episode 3
Allison Hartly
24
Unemployed
Eliminated Episode 2
Dominic O'Halloran
25
Special Effects Artist
Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants
Episodes
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Calvin
9th
3rd
8th
2nd
3rd
4th
BTM 2
BTM 2
2nd
2nd
WINNER
Danielle
3rd
5th
5th
5th
7th
6th
2nd
4th
BTM 2
3rd
ACCOMPLICE
Kendra
2nd
2nd
BTM 3
3rd
6th
BTM 2
4th
WIN
3rd
WIN
SECOND
Gage
WIN
BTM 3
4th
BTM 2
WIN
2nd
5th
2nd
WIN
OUT
Lindsay
8th
9th
3rd
WIN
4th
3rd
3rd
3rd
OUT
Sheiry
5th
8th
7th
7th
BTM 2
WIN
WIN
OUT
Chloe
6th
7th
WIN
6th
5th
5th
OUT
Lou Ann
BTM 3
WIN
2nd
BTM 3
2nd
OUT
Noah
7th
BTM 2
6th
4th
OUT
Shaw
4th
6th
BTM 2
OUT
Jorge
BTM 2
4th
OUT
Allison
10th
OUT
Dominic
OUT
Season 5 [ ]
Investigator
Age
Occupation
Outcome
Amy Yee
24
Film Student
Winner
Cleo Yokofski
64
Retired Teacher
Accomplice
Morgan Duenk
24
Model
Runner-Up
Brandon Gallant
23
Barista
Eliminated Finale
Evan Marshall
30
OBGYN Doctor
Eliminated Episode 9
Ola Noordwyck
54
Custodian
Eliminated Episode 8
Steven March
50
Private Investigator
Eliminated Episode 7
Bhriana Delarosa
18
Model
Eliminated Episode 6
Max Lynn
24
Personal Shopper
Eliminated Episode 5
Nich Levesque
18
Student
Eliminated Episode 4
Marlee O'Tallon
35
Hotel Sales Manager
Eliminated Episode 3
Nathaniel McNeal
19
Student
Eliminated Episode 3
Julie Remaros
24
Bartender
Eliminated Episode 2
Alec Rodgers
27
Lab Technician
Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants
Episodes
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Amy
7th
WIN
7th
BTM 2
4th
4th
4th
BTM 2
2nd
WIN
WINNER
Cleo
9th
4th
3rd
5th
2nd
WIN
2nd
WIN
BTM 2
3rd
ACCOMPLICE
Morgan
BTM 3
7th
2nd
2nd
WIN
2nd
3rd
3rd
WIN
2nd
SECOND
Brandon
WIN
6th
WIN
BTM 3
5th
5th
WIN
4th
3rd
OUT
Evan
4th
BTM 3
BTM 3
WIN
3rd
3rd
5th
2nd
OUT
Ola
6th
2nd
4th
3rd
BTM 2
BTM 2
BTM 2
OUT
Steven
5th
BTM 2
8th
4th
7th
7th
OUT
Bhriana
BTM 2
9th
6th
7th
6th
OUT
Max
10th
3rd
5th
6th
OUT
Nich
2nd
10th
9th
OUT
Marlee
8th
8th
OUT
Nathaniel
3rd
5th
OUT
Julie
11th
OUT
Alec
OUT
Season 6 - All Stars [ ]
Investigator
Age
Occupation
Previous
Outcome
Rebecca Thomas
34
TV News Anchor
Season 1
3rd
Winner
De'rel Shaw
25
Door-to-Door Salesman
Season 3
6th
Accomplice
Aleksandra "Allie" Mole
19
Model
Season 2
Runner-Up
Runner-Up
Ola Noordwyck
54
Custodian
Season 5
5th
Eliminated Episode 11
Ceri Hazelwood
29
Nanny
Season 3
Accomplice
Eliminated Episode 10
Natalie Brown
29
Nurse
Season 2
Winner
Eliminated Episode 9
Gage Rue
29
Tattoo Artist
Season 4
3rd
Eliminated Episode 8
Samantha LeBlanc
19
Model
Season 1
Runner-Up
Eliminated Episode 7
Matthew "Matt" Garnier
34
Parametic
Season 3
Accomplice
Eliminated Episode 6
Lou Ann Montgomery
50
Crossing Guard
Season 4
7th
Eliminated Episode 5
Laura Borden
47
Postal Worker
Season 3
Winner
Eliminated Episode 4
Gregory Flatts
36
Real Estate Agent
Season 1
Winner
Eliminated Episode 3
Angel Symone
18
Student/Model
Season 2
5th
Eliminated Episode 2
Roy Hornsby
56
Football Coach
Season 2
Accomplice
Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants
Episodes
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Rebecca
5th
BTM 3
5th
6th
WIN
2nd
6th
BTM 2
3rd
BTM 2
2nd
WINNER
De'rel
8th
9th
6th
7th
2nd
WIN
2nd
5th
4th
2nd
3rd
ACCOMPLICE
Allie
3rd
3rd
9th
4th
6th
5th
WIN
WIN
BTM 2
3rd
WIN
SECOND
Ola
10th
WIN
WIN
2nd
5th
7th
BTM 2
4th
2nd
WIN
OUT
Ceri
2nd
8th
8th
8th
7th
BTM 2
3rd
2nd
WIN
OUT
Natalie
9th
2nd
BTM 2
WIN
4th
3rd
5th
3rd
OUT
Gage
WIN
6th
4th
BTM 3
8th
6th
4th
OUT
Samantha
4th
5th
7th
3rd
3rd
4th
OUT
Matt
6th
4th
BTM 3
5th
BTM 2
OUT
Lou Ann
7th
BTM 2
2nd
BTM 2
OUT
Laura
11th
10th
3rd
OUT
Gregory
BTM 3
7th
OUT
Angel
BTM 2
OUT
Roy
OUT
Season 7 [ ]
Investigator
Age
Occupation
Outcome
Roscoe "Ross" Finland
45
Stay-at-Home Dad
Winner
Karen Hickey
54
Retail Associate
Accomplice
Rachel Wright
24
Teacher
Runner-Up
Ellenmarie Gibson
68
Retired Sales Manager
Eliminated Finale
Blare Rydeout
18
Student
Eliminated Finale
Grendel Moore
65
Retired Flight Attendant
Eliminated Episode 9
Karen-Jayne "K.J." Lutz
49
Radio Announcer
Eliminated Episode 8
Michael "Mike" Rosales
36
Personal Trainer
Eliminated Episode 7
Frankie Mahone
27
Photographer
Eliminated Episode 6
Lynsay O'Ryan
26
Exotic Dancer
Eliminated Episode 5
Jolie Chin
24
Student
Eliminated Episode 4
Gene Quinlon
56
Loss Prevention Manager
Eliminated Episode 3
Robert "Rob" MacFarland
36
Hotel Manager
Eliminated Episode 2
Erinly "Erin" Southwick
19
Model
Eliminated Episode 2
Jillian MacLean
29
Social Worker
Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants
Episodes
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Ross
5th
10th
6th
3rd
4th
BTM 2
3rd
WIN
3rd
WIN
WINNER
Karen
7th
WIN
2nd
4th
6th
5th
BTM 2
3rd
2nd
3rd
ACCOMPLICE
Rachel
WIN
11th
BTM 3
5th
WIN
4th
5th
2nd
WIN
2nd
SECOND
Ellenmarie
BTM 2
5th
WIN
WIN
5th
2nd
WIN
5th
BTM 2
OUT
Blare
3rd
6th
4th
6th
BTM 3
7th
2nd
BTM 2
4th
OUT
Grendel
4th
8th
BTM 2
BTM 2
3rd
3rd
6th
4th
OUT
K.J.
10th
9th
3rd
7th
2nd
6th
4th
OUT
Mike
8th
3rd
8th
BTM 3
7th
WIN
OUT
Frankie
9th
2nd
5th
8th
BTM 2
OUT
Lynsay
BTM 4
7th
7th
2nd
OUT
Jolie
BTM 3
4th
9th
OUT
Gene
2nd
BTM 3
OUT
Rob
6th
OUT
Erin
11th
OUT
Jillian
OUT
Season 8 [ ]
Investigator
Age
Occupation
Outcome
Ari Jigello
27
Event Organizer
Winner
Tony James
44
Resturant Manager
Accomplice
Ezequiel Brooks
18
Student
Runner-Up
Renata Reyes
24
Model
Eliminated Finale
Cameron Applegate
18
Student
Eliminated Episode 9
Monica Torrey
26
Unemployed
Eliminated Episode 8
Tobias Boulard
24
Artist
Eliminated Episode 7
Jessica Mather
19
Model
Eliminated Episode 6
Teslo Antonov
27
Musician
Eliminated Episode 6
Phelicia Bleu
19
Sales Associate
Eliminated Episode 5
Sprague Greenwich
25
Actress
Eliminated Episode 4
Kim Yu
25
Architect
Eliminated Episode 3
Michelle Toro
28
Investment Banker
Eliminated Episode 2
Marvin Flores
19
Student
Eliminated Episode 1
Adriano Pedro
26
Chef
Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants
Episodes
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Ari
WIN
8th
3rd
3rd
BTM 2
BTM 3
4th
4th
2nd
3rd
WINNER
Tony
5th
4th
BTM 2
6th
WIN
WIN
2nd
WIN
BTM 2
2nd
ACCOMPLICE
Ezequiel
9th
6th
5th
WIN
2nd
6th
3rd
2nd
WIN
WIN
SECOND
Renata
2nd
WIN
2nd
BTM 3
BTM 3
2nd
BTM 2
BTM 2
3rd
OUT
Cameron
4th
2nd
9th
7th
6th
5th
5th
3rd
OUT
Monica
11th
BTM 2
8th
5th
4th
4th
WIN
OUT
Tobias
8th
5th
7th
4th
7th
3rd
OUT
Jessica
7th
BTM 3
4th
8th
5th
OUT
Teslo
3rd
3rd
BTM 3
BTM 2
3rd
OUT
Phelicia
BTM 2
9th
6th
2nd
OUT
Sprague
10th
10th
WIN
OUT
Kim
6th
7th
OUT
Michelle
BTM 3
OUT
Marvin
OUT
Adriano
Season 9 - Couples [ ]
Investigator
Age
Occupation
Relationship
Outcome
Davis Moore
23
PHD Student
Step-Brothers
Winner
Craig Hanlon
27
Construction Worker
Accomplice
Laura Crawford
24
NFL Cheerleader
Teammates
Runner-Up
Brooke Burns
24
NFL Cheerleader
Third Place
Rachel Clawson
30
Human Resource Manager
Childhood Friends
Eliminated Episode 6
Rachel Dwyer
29
Shoe Designer
Brandon Stevenson
20
Student
Dating
Eliminated Episode 6
Tiffany Emerald
20
Student
Bianca Richards
24
Massage Therapist
Dating
Eliminated Episode 5
Ryan Alexa
30
Teacher
Jane Myers
58
Cafeteria Chef
Mother/Son
Eliminated Episode 4
Evan Myers
25
Software Developer
Penelope Granger
49
Social Worker
Mother/Daughter
Eliminated Episode 3
Samantha Granger
18
Student
Kile Martin
19
Student
Siblings
Eliminated Episode 2
Kaitlin Martin
24
Model/Bartender
Dale Scout
47
Correctional Officer
Best Friends
Eliminated Episode 1
Rex Gharrington
49
Mechanic
David "Dave" Paul
65
Retired Cop
Grandparents
Eliminated Episode 1
Janet Paul
60
Retail Manager
Contestants
Episodes
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Davis Craig
3rd
WIN
WIN
WIN
3rd
BTM 2
WIN
WINNER
ACCOMPLICE
Laura Brooke
WIN
5th
3rd
4th
BTM 2
WIN
2nd
SECOND
THIRD
Rachel Rachel
4th
6th
4th
3rd
2nd
2nd
OUT
Brandon Tiffany
5th
2nd
2nd
BTM 2
WIN
OUT
Bianca Ryan
6th
4th
BTM 2
2nd
OUT
Jane Evan
2nd
BTM 2
5th
OUT
Samantha Penelope
BTM 2
3rd
OUT
Kile Kaitlin
7th
OUT
Dale Rex
OUT
Dave Janet
Season 10 [ ]
Investigator
Age
Occupation
Outcome
Eryn Stewert
18
Student
Winner
Giorgio Eatmon
39
Lawyer
Accomplice
Chandi Gilmore
40
Stay-at-Home Mother
Runner-Up
Nicole Dennings
30
Lawyer
Eliminated Finale
Ashley Laurence
19
Student
Eliminated Episode 9
Louise Freeman
54
Bank Teller
Eliminated Episode 8
Drew Haskel
19
Model
Eliminated Episode 7
Jennifer Graham-Treatonhill
36
Television Producer
Eliminated Episode 6
Darieul Strauss
19
Student
Eliminated Episode 5
Scot Fellos
40
Retail Clerk
Eliminated Episode 4
Jimmy April
43
Record Store Owner
Eliminated Episode 3
Maximo Donati
18
Student
Eliminated Episode 2
Amanda McGraw
28
Human Resource Manager
Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants
Episodes
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Eryn
2nd
BTM 3
7th
WIN
BTM 2
6th
2nd
WIN
WIN
WIN
WINNER
Giorgio
9th
3rd
2nd
6th
5th
4th
BTM 2
2nd
3rd
2nd
ACCOMPLICE
Chandi
3rd
2nd
3rd
3rd
2nd
5th
5th
BTM 2
BTM 2
3rd
SECOND
Nicole
WIN
WIN
6th
7th
3rd
3rd
WIN
3rd
2nd
OUT
Ashley
7th
6th
5th
BTM 2
7th
WIN
4th
4th
OUT
Louise
6th
7th
BTM 3
4th
WIN
2nd
3rd
OUT
Drew
BTM 2
4th
WIN
BTM 3
4th
BTM 2
OUT
Jennifer
5th
9th
BTM 2
5th
6th
OUT
Darieul
4th
BTM 2
8th
2nd
OUT
Scot
BTM 3
5th
4th
OUT
Jimmy
10th
8th
OUT
Maximo
8th
OUT
Amanda
OUT
Season 11 - Second Chances [ ]
Investigator
Age
Previous
Outcome
Bhriana Delarosa
18
Season 5
7th
Winner
Adriano Pedro
26
Season 8
14th
Accomplice
Phelicia Bleu
19
Season 8
9th
Runner-Up
Jillian McLean
29
Season 7
14th
Eliminated Finale
Olivia Carmichael
27
Season 1
9th
Eliminated Episode 9
Jolie Chin
24
Season 7
10th
Eliminated Episode 8
Max Lynn
24
Season 5
8th
Eliminated Episode 7
Marlee O'Tallon
35
Season 5
10th
Eliminated Episode 6
Ciera Marsch
24
Season 2
10th
Eliminated Episode 5
Lynsay O'Ryan
26
Season 7
9th
Eliminated Episode 4
Yvette Griswald
49
Season 1
7th
Eliminated Episode 3
Kaitlin Martin
24
Season 9
8th
Eliminated Episode 3
Sprague Greenwich
30
Season 8
10th
Eliminated Episode 2
Maximo Donati
18
Season 10
11th
Eliminated Episode 1
Rascal Carmichael
30
Season 1
12th
Eliminated Episode 1
Lachlan Earch
34
Season 2
8th
Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants
Episodes
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Bhriana
BTM 5
3rd
4th
BTM 2
2nd
6th
3rd
4th
2nd
2nd
WINNER
Adriano
4th
2nd
6th
4th
WIN
5th
WIN
BTM 2
BTM 2
3rd
ACCOMPLICE
Phelicia
6th
9th
WIN
5th
5th
2nd
4th
2nd
WIN
WIN
SECOND
Jillian
WIN
5th
2nd
7th
BTM 2
WIN
BTM 2
3rd
3rd
OUT
Olivia
9th
WIN
9th
2nd
4th
BTM 2
2nd
WIN
OUT
Jolie
3rd
7th
3rd
3rd
6th
4th
5th
OUT
Max
10th
6th
BTM 3
WIN
7th
3rd
OUT
Marlee
2nd
8th
8th
BTM 3
3rd
OUT
Ciera
5th
BTM 3
7th
6th
OUT
Lynsay
BTM 4
4th
5th
OUT
Yvette
7th
10th
OUT
Kaitlin
8th
BTM 2
OUT
Sprague
BTM 3
OUT
Rascal
OUT
Maximo
OUT
Lachlan
Season 12 - All Stars [ ]
Investigator
Age
Occupation
Previous
Outcome
Tony James
44
Resturant Manager
Season 8
Accomplice
Winner
Laura Crawford
24
NFL Cheerleader
Season 9
2nd
Accomplice
Adriano Pedro
26
Chef
Season 8/11
14th/Accomplice
Runner-Up
Chandi Gilmore
40
Stay-at-Home Mother
Season 10
2nd
Eliminated Episode 10
Davis Moore
23
PHD Student
Season 9
Winner
Eliminated Episode 9
Rachel Wright
24
Teacher
Season 7
2nd
Eliminated Episode 8
Giorgio Eatmon
39
Lawyer
Season 10
Accomplice
Eliminated Episode 7
Craig Hanlon
27
Construction Worker
Season 9
Accomplice
Eliminated Episode 6
Jillian McLean
19
Social Worker
Season 7/11
14th/3rd
Eliminated Episode 5
Karen Hickey
54
Retail Associate
Season 7
Accomplice
Eliminated Episode 4
Ezequiel Brooks
18
Student
Season 8
2nd
Eliminated Episode 4
Nicole Dennings
30
Lawyer
Season 10
3rd
Eliminated Episode 3
Ellenmarie Gibson
68
Retired Sales Manager
Season 7
3rd
Eliminated Episode 3
Renata Reyes
24
Model
Season 8
3rd
Eliminated Episode 2
Phelicia Bleu
19
Sales Associate
Season 8/11
9th/2nd
Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants
Episodes
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Tony
8th
WIN
6th
WIN
3rd
6th
BTM 2
3rd
3rd
3rd
WINNER
Laura
WIN
11th
2nd
4th
6th
3rd
5th
2nd
BTM 2
2nd
ACCOMPLICE
Adriano
7th
6th
3rd
8th
WIN
2nd
4th
BTM 2
WIN
WIN
SECOND
Chandi
BTM 4
2nd
7th
2nd
4th
BTM 2
WIN
WIN
2nd
OUT
Davis
5th
10th
9th
6th
2nd
WIN
3rd
4th
OUT
Rachel
2nd
8th
4th
3rd
BTM 2
5th
2nd
OUT
Giorgio
4th
9th
BTM 3
BTM 3
7th
4th
OUT
Craig
10th
4th
BTM 2
BTM 2
5th
OUT
Jillian
11th
BTM 2
WIN
5th
OUT
Karen
9th
BTM 3
5th
OUT
Ezequiel
3rd
5th
8th
OUT
Nicole
BTM 2
7th
OUT
Ellenmarie
6th
3rd
OUT
Renata
BTM 3
OUT
Phelicia
OUT
Season 13 [ ]
Investigator
Age
Occupation
Outcome
Evan Parker
21
Computer Progammer
Winner
Jih Thao
20
Student
Accomplice
Katerina Austen
19
Cashier
Runner-Up
Nathally Sullivan
30
Real Estate Agent
Eliminated Finale
Shmuel Frank
23
Student
Eliminated Episode 9
Ishmael "Ish" Jackson
27
Dance Club D.J.
Eliminated Episode 8
Jack Donnelson
40
Video Game Designer
Eliminated Episode 7
Gina Anne Munroe
49
Office Manager
Eliminated Episode 6
Richardo Olivero
37
Salsa Dance Instructor
Eliminated Episode 6
Cristann Ritckcher
24
Student
Eliminated Episode 5
Natalie Richards
26
Substitute Teacher
Eliminated Episode 4
Sienna Crook-Eastlen
18
Model
Eliminated Episode 3
Carlos Rigera
47
Chef
Eliminated Episode 2
Malcolm "Brig" Briggs
37
Basketball Coach
Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants
Episodes
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Evan
WIN
5th
BTM 3
5th
2nd
4th
5th
3rd
3rd
3rd
WINNER
Jih
5th
3rd
WIN
8th
3rd
2nd
WIN
WIN
2nd
WIN
ACCOMPLICE
Katerina
2nd
4th
9th
7th
4th
5th
2nd
BTM 2
WIN
2nd
SECOND
Nathally S.
3rd
10th
3rd
2nd
6th
BTM 2
BTM 2
2nd
BTM 2
OUT
Shmuel
7th
BTM 2
7th
3rd
WIN
6th
4th
4th
OUT
Ish
6th
WIN
4th
BTM 3
BTM 2
WIN
3rd
OUT
Jack
BTM 4
7th
5th
WIN
8th
3rd
OUT
Gina Anne
8th
6th
2nd
4th
7th
OUT
Ricardo
9th
2nd
BTM 2
6th
5th
OUT
Cristann
4th
BTM 3
6th
BTM 2
OUT
Natalie R.
BTM 2
8th
8th
OUT
Sienna
BTM 3
9th
OUT
Carlos
10th
OUT
Brig
OUT
Season 14 [ ]
Investigator
Age
Occupation
Outcome
Eduardo "Ed" Rio
21
Band Member
Winner
Carolana Martinez
45
Language Teacher
Accomplice
Natalie Pac
25
Photographer
Runner-Up
Nathally Sullivan
30
Real Estate Agent
Eliminated Finale
Marshall Christian
23
Blogger
Eliminated Episode 9
Donald "Don" Winnefreid
56
Business Owner
Eliminated Episode 8
Shanus MacShannon
40
Production Assistant
Eliminated Episode 8
Kellee Klazik
19
Musician
Eliminated Episode 6
Ginny Mixon
42
Freelance Artist
Eliminated Episode 5
Brandon Natthews
26
Law Student
Eliminated Episode 4
Kristyn Macconi
18
Model
Eliminated Episode 3
Carlos Maya
40
Unemployed
Eliminated Episode 2
Vanessa Morgan
21
Actress
Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants
Episodes
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Ed
5th
WIN
7th
5th
4th
3rd
5th
4th
2nd
2nd
WINNER
Carolana
6th
4th
2nd
7th
2nd
5th
WIN
2nd
WIN
WIN
ACCOMPLICE
Natalie
7th
BTM 3
WIN
2nd
3rd
2nd
BTM 2
3rd
3rd
3rd
SECOND
Pam
2nd
2nd
4th
BTM 3
6th
WIN
3rd
BTM 2
BTM 2
OUT
Marshall
8th
3rd
BTM 3
4th
BTM 2
BTM 2
4th
WIN
OUT
Don
3rd
6th
5th
BTM 2
WIN
4th
2nd
OUT
Shanus
WIN
7th
6th
WIN
7th
6th
SAVED
OUT
Kellee
BTM 3
8th
8th
3rd
5th
OUT
Ginny
BTM 2
5th
BTM 2
6th
OUT
Brandon
4th
9th
3rd
OUT
Kristyn
9th
BTM 2
OUT
Carlos
10th
OUT
Vanessa
OUT
Season 15 - Old & New [ ]
Investigator
Age
Occupation
Previous
Outcome
Yul Huang
30
Doctor
Winner
Kieran MacDonald
19
Student
The Accomplice
Laura Lafayette
19
Cheerleader
Runner-Up
Jodi King
40
Stay-at-Home Mom
Eliminated Finale
Cameron Taunce
24
Soccer Player
Eliminated Episode 11
Monica Torrey
26
Unemployed
Season 8 - 5th
Eliminated Episode 10
De'rel Shaw
25
Sales
Season 3/6 - 6th/Accomplice
Eliminated Episode 9
Lou Ann Montgomery
50
Crossing Guard
Season 4/6 - 7th/9th
Eliminated Episode 7
Teslo Antonov
27
Musician
Season 8 - 8th
Eliminated Episode 6
Stacey Kimball
24
Fashion Designer
Eliminated Episode 5
Corrinn Stanley
70
Retired Principal
Eliminated Episode 4
Ola Noordwyck
54
Custodian
Season 5/6 - 5th/3rd
Eliminated Episode 3
Regine Francis
64
Retired Teacher
Season 1 - Accomplice
Eliminated Episode 2
Aleksandra "Allie" Mole
19
Model
Season 2/6 - 2nd/2nd
Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants
Episodes
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Yul
9th
4th
3rd
8th
2nd
BTM2
2nd
WIN
WIN
3rd
3rd
3rd
WINNER
Kieran
BTM4
2nd
6th
3rd
5th
WIN
4th
5th
4th
WIN
BTM2
2nd
ACCOMPLICE
Laura
2nd
7th
4th
WIN
BTM2
3rd
5th
BTM2
3rd
4th
2nd
WIN
SECOND
Jodi
8th
WIN
8th
5th
WIN
4th
6th
3rd
2nd
BTM2
WIN
OUT
Cameron
3rd
9th
2nd
7th
4th
7th
WIN
2nd
BTM2
2nd
OUT
Monica
6th
8th
5th
2nd
6th
2nd
BTM2
4th
5th
OUT
De'rel
WIN
3rd
BTM3
4th
7th
5th
3rd
SAVED
OUT
Lou Ann
7th
6th
BTM2
BTM2
3rd
6th
OUT
Telso
4th
10th
9th
6th
8th
OUT
Stacey
5th
BTM3
WIN
BTM3
OUT
Corrinn
BTM2
5th
7th
OUT
Ola
10th
BTM2
OUT
Regine
BTM3
OUT
Allie
OUT
Season 16 [ ]
Investigator
Age
Occupation
Outcome
Heather Smithson
34
Nurse
Winner
Emerald Finlay
29
Dental Hygentist
Accomplice
Candice Brown
20
Student
Runner-Up
Claus MacKinnon
63
Retired Air Force Marshall
Eliminated Episode 11
Petra Hearon
50
Dog Breeder
Eliminated Episode 11
Marcie Hanlon
40
Stay-at-Home Mom
Eliminated Episode 9
Brody Blare
18
Student
Eliminated Episode 8
Emmett Hughsler
25
Mechanic
Eliminated Episode 7
Greyson Blois
18
Unemployed
Eliminated Episode 6
Tallon Evanhoff
28
Club Promoter
Eliminated Episode 5
Brandy Rihanna
26
Singer/Preformer
Eliminated Episode 4
Tallah Evanhoff
28
Medical Student
Eliminated Episode 3
Alec Peters
20
Model
Eliminated Episode 2
Nick Verega
23
Actor
Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants
Episodes
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Heather
2nd
2nd
4th
6th
BTM2
2nd
WIN
BTM2
2nd
2nd
2nd
WINNER
Emerald
4th
3rd
WIN
2nd
WIN
5th
BTM2
2nd
WIN
BTM2
3rd
ACCOMPLICE
Candice
8th
8th
3rd
BTM2
5th
6th
5th
WIN
3rd
WIN
WIN
SECOND
Claus
BTM2
7th
6th
4th
8th
3rd
4th
4th
4th
3rd
OUT
Petra
WIN
5th
5th
WIN
4th
4th
2nd
5th
BTM2
SAVED
OUT
Marcie
9th
10th
9th
5th
7th
7th
3rd
3rd
OUT
Brody
7th
6th
BTM3
7th
6th
WIN
6th
OUT
Emmett
10th
WIN
2nd
8th
3rd
BTM2
OUT
Greyson
3rd
BTM3
BTM2
3rd
2nd
OUT
Tallon
5th
4th
7th
BTM3
OUT
Brandy
6th
BTM2
8th
OUT
Tallah
BTM3
9th
OUT
Alec
BTM4
OUT
Nick
OUT
Season 17 [ ]
Investigator
Age
Occupation
Outcome
Danielle "Danni" Richardmyer
29
Tattoo Artist
Winner
Mailyss O'Deagen
51
Special Ed. Teacher
Accomplice
Teri Boyd
47
Special Ed. Teacher
Runner-Up
Claus MacKinnon
63
Retired Air Force Marshall
Eliminated Episode 11
Robbie "Rob" McFadzen
35
Doctor
Eliminated Episode 10
Tonya Carleton
40
Business Owner
Eliminated Episode 9
Kimberly "Kim" Whynlman
34
Professional Dancer
Eliminated Episode 8
Scott Hughes
42
Tailor
Eliminated Episode 7
Bruno Macknaloni
26
Customer Service Rep.
Eliminated Episode 6
Mckenzie Greene
18
Student
Eliminated Episode 5
River Del Torres
29
Recording Artist
Eliminated Episode 4
Terry Ovalby
49
Football Coach
Eliminated Episode 3
Jessome Peters
25
Model
Eliminated Episode 2
Catherine "Cat" Morales
19
Student
Eliminated Episode 1
Contestants
Episodes
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Danni
WIN
5th
3rd
6th
7th
5th
6th
4th
BTM2
3rd
2nd
WINNER
Mailyss
2nd
WIN
8th
WIN
8th
6th
3rd
5th
3rd
WIN
WIN
ACCOMPLICE
Teri B.
7th
8th
2nd
4th
WIN
2nd
4th
2nd
WIN
BTM2
3rd
SECOND
Sarah
5th
7th
5th
8th
BTM2
7th
WIN
BTM2
2nd
2nd
OUT
Rob
BTM3
3rd
9th
5th
4th
3rd
2nd
WIN
4th
OUT
Tonya
6th
2nd
WIN
BTM3
2nd
BTM2
BTM2
3rd
OUT
Kim
9th
6th
BTM2
2nd
6th
4th
5th
OUT
Scott
3rd
BTM3
BTM3
BTM2
5th
WIN
OUT
Bruno
BTM2
4th
7th
7th
3rd
OUT
Mckenzie
10th
9th
6th
3rd
OUT
River
BTM4
10th
4th
OUT
Terry O.
4th
BTM2
OUT
Jessome
8th
OUT
Cat
OUT